How do critters survive in the concrete jungle? It takes smarts

Scott Halleran / Getty Images

A marmoset looks on during the final round of the LPGA Brazil Cup at the Itanhanga Golf Club in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.

Crows in Japan have the strangest habit. They carry nuts in their beak and drop them on crosswalks. Passing cars run over them, cracking them. It's not just that the crows have outsourced the heavy lifting, they've even come to realize that it's easier to collect their reward on a section of asphalt where traffic consistently stops, and then goes.

Foxes, songbirds — even whales — have something in common with those wily crows from Japan. When they wound up in a man-made city habitat (or a human-impacted area), they've come up with new tricks to survive. What about the animals that can't adapt so well? It's up to humans to adjust their behavior for the sake of the critters, say researchers.

In their new paper in Animal Behavior, Daniel Sol and collaborators at Catalonia's Center for Ecological Research and Forestry Applications survey species who've learned to make the most of their new circumstances when humans started meddling with their natural habitat. It's not uncommon for species to change when their environment shifts, but behavioral changes for urban life tend to be the most spectacular, Sol told NBC News.

Scientists have drummed up a long list of behavioral changes that have allowed small mammals and birds to get comfortable in cities around the globe:

  • The black-capped chickadee belts out a shorter, shriller song when it needs to be heard over the sound of moving traffic. When traffic noise subsided, they return to a slower, deeper melody that is more familiar to potential mates. Its flexibility is part of what makes it a successful urban dweller.
  • Pigeons have become used to human hands feeding them, so much so they can now recognize their regulars when they show up with birdseed. But not all people are pigeon-friendly, the birds have learned. They also quickly learned to avoid humans who had previously chased them away.
  • Similarly, urban mockingbirds in North Carolina learned to recognize people who had threatened their nests fairly quickly. 
  • Near Bristol in the UK, traveling urban red foxes now tend to cross roads more often at night, when they are less likely to be hit by a car.
  • Black tufted marmosets living in a public park in Belo Horizonte, Brazil, avoided noisy sections of it, even if there is plenty of food to be had there, and instead move to quieter locations.
  • Coyotes have made themselves at home in cities like Chicago, where they live in public parks, and among apartment complexes and industrial buildings. If you watched "The Lion King," you may have guessed that they usually hunt in packs, but the urban coyote flies solo and prefers to hunt at night. Coyotes even seem to be doing a bit of good, however unknowingly — they control the spread of Canada geese in the city by sneaking up on their nests and stealing their eggs.

And out in the ocean, where there's no sign of city life, man-made sonar tends to challenge the typical behavior of whales. Single male humpback whales sing for hours during the breeding season, in what scientists believe is a mating display. So when sonar interfered with their serenade, their songs got even longer. (Though, data made public later showed that this isn't always the case. When the military tests their sonar equipment, whales stop diving for food and singing.)

Why are some animals better city dwellers? A species might naturally be a curious, bold sort — that would give it an advantage. Another possibility is that cities select for certain genetic traits, so the songbird that survives in city is one that is biologically different from its country cousin. But so far, it looks like it's the most innovative species, like the careful foxes and nut-cracking crows and song-switching birds, that stand the best chance, Sol explains. If they can change their behavior, they're most likely to do well.

Species set in their ways may have a harder time, Sol says, but there are ways we can help. Breaking up the concrete some and building green spaces and parks helps new species find their feet. "If the environment is more similar, [if] they contain gardens, more green space, then birds or other animals can do much better," Sol says.

Of course, neatly trimmed hedges and astroturf aren't a complete replacement of the wooded homes most animals enjoyed. "We need to build cities that have more gardens and parks, but we also need to maintain natural habitats as they are because they are crucial for biodiversity," he says.

Nidhi Subbaraman writes about science and technology. Follow on Google+, Twitter, Facebook.

Discuss this post

Cool monkey. How effortlessly he clings to that concrete tree!

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 3:20 PM EST

What on earth does the Lion King have to do with coyotes? Those are hyenas....they're not even canines....

  • 2 votes
Reply#2 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 3:52 PM EST

Kitsune,

You're right about the hyenas in "The Lion Kings," but wrong about their species, they are members of the canine family.

However, writer Nidhi Subbaraman is not only wrong, but as a "sci/tech writer," misinformed to the point of being damn dumb. How in Hell could a non-aquatic mammal navigate from the savannahs of Africa to the North American West, or vice versa?

In the last century, coyotes have been migrating West as the wolf populations were killed off. The Eastern coyote is a larger critter than its Western counterpart. So much so that Westerners transplated to the East are gobsmacked by their size, +- 50 pounds to the -30 pound coyotes of my native Montana. The coyote population of Massachusetts is sufficiently large that a Boston College wildlife biologist undertook a lenghty study of coyotes on OLD Cape Cod. (No surprise that coyotes hang out in Chicago.)

Eastern coyotes are large because as their ancestors migrated East they mated with the Northernwest Grey Wolf or the Southwest Red Wolf depending upon the route they followed. This was confirmed by the BC biologist in the extensive DNA studies he conducted. These hook ups not only created a larger hybrid, but knocked out the Old Husbands' Tale that wolves always kill coyotes. The scientist has suggested that Eastern Coyotes, might be more correctly named "coywolves."

Subbaraman is right that coyotes prey on geese, so much so that MA cities and towns wishing to rid parks, beaches, playfields, etc. of geese and their plentiful poop, invest in rather cheesy looking plastic coyotes to scare the geese away. Ravens and crows being "wicked smaat" may been seen perching on the decoys. In addition to noshing on geese, coyotes prey on town and country mice, moles, rats, and deer (the BC biologist found venison to be a signicant part of the Cape critters' diet. He speculates but hasn't yet confirmed that they may form packs to bring down healthy adults, in addition to single or mother/pup combos who prey on fawns or injured adults. Finally, much to the sorrow of careless pet owners, Bay State coyotes (like cousins in Chicago) add outdoor cats and off-lease Jack Russells to their ever expanding cuisine.

Not that my Montana relatives want to hear this, I find Eastern coyotes to be a very handsome animal. However, I keep my dear kitties in the house.

    #2.1 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 7:53 PM EST

    Malinda, if you check you will find that hyenas are not canines--they are more closely related to cats than to dogs but aren't particularly close to either.

    As for a non-aquatic mammal navigating from the savannahs of Africa to the North American west, mastodons, mammoths, humans, wolves, dogs, cats, and at least one species of hyena managed to walk across from Siberia during one or the other of several different glaciations.

    • 2 votes
    #2.2 - Sun Mar 10, 2013 12:42 PM EDT
    Reply

    sneaking up on their nests and stealing their eggs.

    You have to sneak up, or the eggs will hear you coming and roll away

    • 2 votes
    Reply#3 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 4:38 PM EST

    They've learned we have food in our garbage and parking lots.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#4 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 4:47 PM EST

    We are encroaching on their habitats and they need to survive in the "jungle" we have created ...

    I remember when coyotes wouldn't go near people at all -- scared of people -- now they're less afraid people. They know where the food is and if it means going near people they will. My father was once on military maneuvers in the desert and he slowly coaxed a coyote into coming closer to the camp by leaving our opened canned rations out for the coyote. The coyote came closer and closer all the while losing its fear of the men.

      Reply#5 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 8:13 PM EST

      I have been hunting coyotes for fifty years and they don't hunt in packs. They do seem to mate for life though. If the so-called pack is checked out, it will consist of the male, the mother and the last litter, it would be better described as a family. Their main food is small animals like mice, rats, and birds and they are not large enough to share with a pack. Once a female is bred she will run off the previous litter.

      • 2 votes
      Reply#6 - Sat Mar 9, 2013 10:26 PM EST

      they have a right to this planet as much as we do,I hope we do a much better of land management then we have in the past.Every empty lot gets developed.Developer's don't care out your quality of life and anything else,it's build and build,and when their all done turning everything into concrete,they run off to their out of the way hideaway.Just remember when all the wild life is gone,were next.

      • 1 vote
      Reply#7 - Sun Mar 10, 2013 3:52 AM EDT

      Deers, skunks, and armadillo's have yet to learn to look both ways before crossing the road. They seem oblivious that cars even exist or are faster then they are. Many dead and squished animals on the road.

      • 1 vote
      Reply#8 - Sun Mar 10, 2013 1:07 PM EDT

      I don't remember Coyotes in the Lion King. As a matter fact are there even Coyotes in Africa?

        Reply#9 - Mon Mar 11, 2013 6:04 AM EDT

        Malinda-3622677

        Kitsune,

        You're right about the hyenas in "The Lion Kings," but wrong about their species, they are members of the canine family.

        That is incorrect Hyenas are part of the Hyaenidae family not Canidae family. Hyenas are more closely related to felines than canines.

          Reply#10 - Mon Mar 11, 2013 6:09 AM EDT

          I didn't know pigeons were that smart. I thought their advantage was in numbers and a willingness to pick through humans' trash.

          A few species the article missed are those generally considered "pests": rats, mice, roaches, and raccoons, which almost certainly don't thrive as well in the wild as they do infesting human houses. But I suppose the article is trying to look at the issue from a point sympathetic with the animals, and those aren't species that inspire sympathy.

            Reply#11 - Mon Mar 11, 2013 11:00 AM EDT
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.