17-month mock Mars mission turns up down-to-Earth sleep problem

Nov. 4, 2011: Six international researchers emerge with smiles from their mock mission to Mars after spending 520 days in a windowless and isolated capsule in Moscow. NBC News' Dara Brown reports.

Astronauts have a down-to-Earth problem that could be even worse on a long trip to Mars: They can't get enough sleep. And over time, the lack of slumber can turn intrepid space travelers into drowsy couch potatoes, a new study shows. 

In a novel experiment, six volunteers were confined in a cramped mock spaceship in Moscow to simulate a 17-month voyage. It made most of the would-be spacemen lethargic, much like birds and bears heading into winter, gearing up for hibernation.

The men went into a prolonged funk. Four had considerable trouble sleeping, with one having minor problems and the sixth mostly unaffected. Some had depression issues. Sometimes, a few of the men squirreled themselves away into the most private nooks they could find. They didn't move much. They avoided crucial exercise.


"This looks like something you see in birds in the winter," said lead author David Dinges, a sleep expert at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine.

The experiment was run and funded by Russian and European space agencies. A report on the simulation's effect on the men was published online Monday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Problem needs fixing
Dinges said scientists can't tell if the men's lethargy was just lack of sleep or was also caused by other factors: the close quarters, lack of privacy with so many cameras or being away from their families for so long.

It's a problem that has to be fixed — and can be — before astronauts are sent to Mars, as President Barack Obama proposes for the mid-2030s, Dinges said. The trip to Mars, Earth's closest neighbor, would take about six months each way.

ESA

Simulation astronauts Diego Urbina and Alexander Smoleyevsky conduct their first Marswalk in a room made up to look like a Martian landscape at the Mars500 experiment facility in Moscow in 2011. The flags of the European Space Agency, Russia and China are visible in the background at right.

The world record for continuous time in space — 14 months — is held by Valery Polyakov, who was on the Russian space station Mir in 1994 and 1995. American astronaut Scott Kelly and Russian cosmonaut Mikhail Kornienko are scheduled to spend an entire year in space on the International Space Station, starting in 2015.

When leaving confinement in November 2011, the six volunteers — three Russians, a Frenchman, an Italian-Colombian and a Chinese — called their experience successful: "We can go forward and now plan to go to Mars and move confidently," said volunteer Romain Charles of France.

The results that scientists collected weren't as rosy. Devices on the volunteers' wrists measured their movements and showed that when they were asleep and awake they were moving much less than they should have been, an unexpected and disturbing finding, Dinges said.

One of the six volunteers — who were paid $100,000 to live in the mock spaceship with limited and time-delayed contact with the outside world — slept nearly half an hour less each night than he did when he started the mission, affecting how he went about his day, Dinges said.

Why it matters
The loss of sleep matters because astronauts will have to perform intricate tasks on the way to Mars and while on the Red Planet. And they have to do vigorous exercises daily to fight the toll that near-zero gravity takes on the bones and other parts of the body. And most of the volunteers weren't doing that.

The Moscow study, based on the ground, couldn't take into account the added difficulty of near-zero gravity.

Former astronaut Michael Lopez-Alegria, who holds the American record for longest space mission, said he could relate to the study findings. During his 215 days in orbit on the space station, he sometimes had trouble getting back to sleep because he didn't have a sense of lying down or having his head on a pillow.

The lack of sleep and lots of work caused him to sometimes nod off during the day, and the lack of gravity meant that when he fell asleep accidentally he would float away and awaken elsewhere in the station, he said.

"It happened more than once, but I never thought it was a big deal. I thought it was amusing in a way," Lopez-Alegria said in an interview.

Excerpts from astronaut diaries in a NASA report show prevalent sleep problems, with space station residents talking about nodding off while typing and obsessing over getting too much or too little sleep.

"I just need sleep," one unidentified astronaut wrote.

"The morning started disastrously. I slept through two (wake-up) alarms... My body apparently went on strike for better working conditions," wrote another.

Feels like a hangover
Jerry Linenger, a medical doctor and NASA astronaut who spent more than four months on the Russian space station Mir in 1997, said he watched cosmonauts fall asleep in mid-conversation. And after a couple months, Linenger started having sleep problems despite his best efforts, which included using eye shades and bungee cords to put pressure on his body.

"It's kind of like you're wiped out after New Year's Eve, kind of like a hangover or something," Linenger said. "You are aware you're not performing. So I'd be extra careful if I had to switch some buttons."

Later in 1997, a cosmonaut on Mir who had a sleepless night accidentally disconnected a system that gathered solar power for the aging station, said Charles Czeisler, a sleep professor and space researcher at Harvard Medical School.

Czeisler, who wasn't part of the Dinges study, said the new work was important in demonstrating the challenges of a Mars mission. 

Astronauts do use sleeping pills to help them sleep. 

And one solution experts like Dinges and Czeisler agree on is lighting. Blue evening light is essential for resetting a body's natural rhythms, Czeisler said, and changing the color and timing of lighting has been shown to help people sleep on Earth.

More about simulated space missions:

Copyright 2013, The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Discuss this post

Granted human biology is fairly universal in how it functions, I can't help but think that there'd be extra attentiveness on the actual mission given the pioneering importance behind it. There'd be more adrenaline and norepinephrine in the actual astronauts' systems that could help them be more alert regardless of sleep loss, at least in minor amounts of sleep loss. The idea they'd be the first people of Mars would absolutely have some impact on their performance and possibly have heightened awareness. Given these experiments were done on Earth, it's missing part of that "new and unknown experience" factor.

I've always found in instances where I've been training for something for years at a time, I found my performance many times degrading due to a variety of circumstances. Many of these things I've trained for are physical or mechanical challenges, but I've always found when it came time to deliver I always found myself excelling beyond the levels that I displayed during training, while during the long durations of practice I'd find my performance somewhat deteriorated due to the lack of "game time mentality".

I understand that it's not quite an apples to apples comparison, but I've tried putting myself in the mindset of such volunteers and found that the lack of 'realism' would ultimately affect how well I performed.

  • 2 votes
Reply#1 - Mon Jan 7, 2013 7:24 PM EST

Ojibobo - adrenaline and norepinephrine work but over a short time span. THe trip to mars and back with exploration is probably in the 17 to 24 month range, the human bidy is not designed to function at a high level for that period of time. By high level I mean stimulated by adrenal hormones etc. I also suspect that those activities that you trained for were of short term duration not multi months.

I agree that the earth bound lack of realism will have some impact on the results of the study, but those results seem to be born out by actual space station observations by crew memebrs.

  • 1 vote
#1.1 - Tue Jan 8, 2013 9:29 AM EST

Ojibobo - adrenaline and norepinephrine work but over a short time span. THe trip to mars and back with exploration is probably in the 17 to 24 month range, the human bidy is not designed to function at a high level for that period of time. By high level I mean stimulated by adrenal hormones etc. I also suspect that those activities that you trained for were of short term duration not multi months.

I agree that the earth bound lack of realism will have some impact on the results of the study, but those results seem to be born out by actual space station observations by crew memebrs.

    #1.2 - Tue Jan 8, 2013 9:29 AM EST

    Sorry about the double post - stupid computer.

    • 1 vote
    #1.3 - Tue Jan 8, 2013 9:30 AM EST
    Reply

    Why not make a ship that can simulate gravity if you take the rotations of earth and put them into a spacecraft that can duplicate near the same rotations you would be able to make simulated gravity . Sure the ship would have to be bigger but why not build a ship that stays in space where you have shuttles to taxi the person to and from the ship to land on earth or a planet. If mankind can build an atom accelerator I know they can build a long range space craft. Get George Lucas to draw the plans up for it ..............

    • 1 vote
    Reply#2 - Tue Jan 8, 2013 10:57 AM EST

    A fascinating study. Good to see we're tackling the more mundane issues as related to extended space flight.

    Exploring this issue further could even yield important information about ordinary, Earth-bound insomnia, since it seems that gravity difference isn't the primary problem. Perhaps there are certain psychological traits that are best for handling extended space travel. Gotta get on this now, before we blast off!

    • 2 votes
    Reply#3 - Tue Jan 8, 2013 11:14 AM EST

    I'd like more info on the 1 out of 6 who apparently was not as affected. It might be a genetic or chemical difference that could be tested for and those traits specifically chosen for long flights. I agree that it would apply to insomnia on earth, and possibly also those who work in antarctica or on submarines, etc. I didn't know that sleeping was such a problem on the space station.

    • 2 votes
    #3.1 - Tue Jan 8, 2013 12:12 PM EST
    Reply

    Wow, pretty interesting study results. And like pog8, I'm curious about the one person whose sleep was unaffected. Was it one of the Russians who was unaffected, or one of the three from separate countries (my first guess is that it was the Chinese who was unaffected due to their national discipline, but perhaps he'd be too high strung or a perfectionist. . . so now I think it was the Italian-Columbian - more laid back, wouldn't be bothered enough to be kept awake at "night". . . just a hunch, not trying to be racist or hateful).

    And talk about a blast from the past! I used to fly with then Lieutenant Lopez-Alegria in the Navy - we called him L. A., great guy, friendly, very "down-to-earth" and easy to relate to. He was a Navy pilot on some of the missions I flew on. I knew he had gone on to become an Astronaut but I didn't know he held the record for staying in space the longest. Pretty cool.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#4 - Wed Jan 16, 2013 2:57 AM EST

    I don't know why we aren't experimenting with magnetic covers for sleeping in zero gravity. Even a magnetic sleeping cap would give the sensation of your head resting on a pillow. I think what they are missing is the snuggly feeling. - RC

    • 1 vote
    Reply#5 - Wed Feb 27, 2013 8:30 PM EST

    What is the point of such a sightseeing mission? Much better sightseeing experience is already possible by satellite imagery. And, every person with a computer can "go" to Mars. Right now.

    It would be different if robots had not already explored Mars from orbit and on the surface. And found something halfway interesting.

    I see nothing "inspirational" about spending national treasure on bragging rights. Just the opposite. It's narcissistic, chauvinistic. We (humans, Americans) got there first. Na na na na na! Foolish thinking.

    We should be working on SMART ROBOTICS as the core of our space exploration program. Getting "there" first bodes a huge economic payback, a commanding lead in sustainable space development, as well as economic leadership here on Earth.

      Reply#6 - Fri Mar 1, 2013 12:55 PM EST
      You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
      As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.